Alex Murdaugh Protection
The Murdaugh household saga has dominated the information after one other taking pictures, a resignation and prison accusations — with Alex Murdaugh on the heart of all of it. Listed below are the most recent updates on Alex Murdaugh.
Paul and Maggie Murdaugh have been shot subsequent to the canine kennels. They died underneath darkish pines in a far nook of the household’s sprawling 1,700-acre searching property in Colleton County. Immediately, the eyes of the world are on their father and husband, Alex Murdaugh, as he goes on trial, accused of their murders.
Worldwide media, the general public and authorized consultants have descended on the Colleton County Courthouse in Walterboro, SC, as jury choice begins. After greater than two years of hypothesis and rumor, exhausting details ought to lastly emerge concerning the brutal killings and gorgeous downfall of considered one of South Carolina’s strongest authorized households. However earlier than the prosecution and protection can argue their case, they have to select residents of Colleton County who will determine Murdaugh’s destiny.
Greater than 900 potential jurors have been have been despatched detailed questionnaires to find out in the event that they have been eligible for jury obligation.
From this physique, protection attorneys and prosecutors from the South Carolina Lawyer Normal’s Workplace will pluck 12 jurors and several other alternates who will decide whether or not Alex Murdaugh, the son of a Lowcountry authorized dynasty, is responsible of murdering his spouse and son.
Since 2019, the Murdaugh case has unfolded in a cascade of sudden twists and darkish revelations. Jurors will likely be anticipated to parse a murky chain of occasions, with solely circumstantial proof to offer form to an important moments within the trial.
In a case outlined by sudden drama, it’s no shock that jury choice must also be completely different. The sheer scale of the potential juror pool is uncommon, in line with a number of attorneys.
“Usually in a rural county like Colleton, you’re not going to summon greater than 150 individuals,” mentioned 1st Circuit Solicitor David Pascoe, whose workplace is just not concerned within the trial.
However veteran choose Clifton Newman, who’s overseeing the trial, has labored to streamline the choice course of. He despatched out an unusually particular questionnaire to potential jurors to slim the pool as a lot as potential upfront.
Jurors who’re summoned will then be requested a sequence of questions, often known as voir dire, designed to tease out their data of the case and any biases that may make them unfit to serve on the jury. Legal professionals on each side will jockey to pick a jury sympathetic to their case.
Discovering a jury in close-knit Colleton County with no data or opinion on the Murdaugh case, or perhaps a previous enterprise or private relationship with the Murdaughs, could also be practically inconceivable. However that isn’t essentially the objective,say attorneys.
“Relationships with the Murdaughs goes to be the overarching concern that comes up in voir dire,” predicted Columbia lawyer Bakari Sellers. “However that’s not essentially disqualifying.”
“The usual is ‘can the juror put these issues apart and be a good and neutral juror?’” Pascoe mentioned.
In the course of the Lexington County trial of Tim Jones, convicted in 2019 of murdering his 5 youngsters, legal professionals wanted two weeks to whittle down 165 potential jurors right into a last panel of 12 jurors and 6 alternates.
The choice course of in Murdaugh’s trial is anticipated to go not less than the remainder of the week. As jurors reply questions on their backgrounds and beliefs, they are often “struck for trigger” and faraway from the jury pool if attorneys consider there’s a reputable purpose they can’t choose the trial pretty.
Each side even have a set variety of “peremptory challenges,” which permits them to take away a possible juror with out giving a purpose. The prosecution is allowed 5 peremptory challenges, the protection has 10.
“The primary factor that would get you disqualified is standing up and saying any time the police arrest somebody they should be responsible,” Sellers mentioned.
Alex Murdaugh — A fourth technology lawyer and inheritor to one of the vital highly effective authorized dynasties in South Carolina. His household managed the 14th Circuit Solicitor’s Workplace, protecting Allendale, Beaufort, Colleton, Hampton and Jasper counties, for nearly 100 years. On the similar time, the household’s regulation agency, PMPED, grew into a private harm powerhouse. Murdaugh served as a volunteer solicitor whereas working as a plaintiff’s lawyer on the household regulation agency. An enormous man with a love of searching, Murdaugh met his spouse, Maggie, at USC. That they had two sons, the youthful, Paul, and his older brother, Buster.
The protection staff — Murdaugh’s lead attorneys are Dick Harpootlian and Jim Griffin. Harpootlian is a state senator and former fifth Circuit solicitor and deputy solicitor who prosecuted serial killer Donald “Pee Wee” Gaskins. The very long time litigator is understood for dramatic thrives and a charismatic courtroom efficiency. Griffin is usually described because the extra reserved and cerebral of the pair, however the former assistant U.S. Lawyer brings a long time of expertise in each prison protection and complicated civil litigation to the trial staff.
Alex Murdaugh sits within the Colleton County Courthouse together with his authorized staff together with Dick Harpootlian and Jim Griffin as his attorneys talk about motions in entrance of Decide Clifton Newman on Friday, Dec. 9, 2022. Murdaugh’s trial for homicide is scheduled to start Jan. 23, 2023 in Walterboro. Tracy Glantz [email protected]
The prosecution — The case is being prosecuted by state Lawyer Normal Alan Wilson’s workplace. Within the courtroom, the lead prosecutor will likely be Creighton Waters, the chief lawyer of the state grand jury. Whereas the state grand jury not often considers homicide circumstances, Waters has adeptly led its investigations into advanced, multi-jurisdictional crimes like human trafficking and drug smuggling. The Murdaugh case was taken by the Lawyer Normal’s workplace after Duffie Stone, the 14th Circuit Solicitor, recused himself from the case. Waters will likely be joined by veteran appellate lawyer Don Zelenka, who has fought quite a few homicide appeals within the S.C. Court docket of Appeals and State Supreme Court docket.
Lawyer Normal Prosecutor Creighton Waters and Protection Lawyer Dick Harpootlian make factors concerning the launch of proof throughout a listening to earlier than Decide Clifton Newman in Florence County on Thursday, Oct. 20, 2022. Tracy Glantz [email protected]
The choose — Clifton Newman, a veteran South Carolina choose who attended segregated colleges and is now one of the vital revered jurists within the state, will likely be overseeing the case. Gentle-spoken however commanding, Newman has overseen different excessive profile circumstances. Amongst them was trial of Nathaniel Rowland, who murdered USC scholar Samantha Josephson after she bought into his automotive believing it was an Uber.
Circuit Decide Clifton Newman speaks throughout a judicial listening to regarding the launch of proof within the Colleton County Courthouse on Monday, Aug. 29, 2022. Tracy Glantz [email protected] Timeline of the case to date
A FATAL BOAT CRASH AND AFTERMATH
A photograph of the Sea Hunt boat after it crashed and killed Mallory Seashore on Feb. 24, 2019. The photograph was launched Monday as a part of the S.C. Lawyer Normal’s Workplace’s case file. S.C. Lawyer Normal’s Workplace
Feb. 24, 2019 — At 2:30 a.m. a dashing boat collides with the pilling of a bridge over Archers Creek in Beaufort County. The six passengers are thrown into the water. One of many passengers, Mallory Seashore, is just not discovered after the crash. Paul Murdaugh is accused of piloting the boat whereas drunk on the time of the crash. Instantly following the wreck, his father and grandfather, the previous native solicitor, prevented sobriety assessments being carried out on Paul. Alex Murdaugh wandered the halls of the hospital, allegedly pressuring witnesses to not converse to the police.
March 3, 2019 — Mallory Seashore’s physique is present in a marshy space of the river.
March 20, 2019 — A wrongful dying lawsuit is filed on behalf of Mallory Seashore’s household in Hampton County. Paul and his father are named defendants. The Seashore household is represented by lawyer Mark Tinsley.
April 18, 2019 — On what would have been Seashore’s twentieth birthday, Paul Murdaugh is indicted on three felony prison expenses associated to the boat crash. Murdaugh hires Jim Griffin and Dick Harpootlian to characterize his son, who pleaded not responsible on Might 6 and was launched on bond.
Sept. 22, 2020 — Mediation breaks down in an effort to settle the wrongful dying lawsuit, in line with Tinsley. A court docket doc says that the session lasted greater than eight hours earlier than reaching an deadlock.
Oct. 16, 2020 — Tinsley information a movement to compel Alex Murdaugh to reveal details about financial institution accounts, belongings and funds. A listening to is initially scheduled for Might 2021 however is moved to June 10, 2021.
JUNE 7, 2021: THE DAY OF THE MURDERS
The Murdaugh dwelling on Moselle Highway, as seen on Sept. 2, 2021, positioned in Islandton, S.C. On June 7, Alex Murdaugh discovered his spouse Maggie and son Paul murdered close to the canine kennels (not pictured). Drew Martin [email protected]
Morning — PMPED staffer confronts Murdaugh and calls for “a solution that day” about lacking charges.
7:56 p.m. — Paul sends Snapchat video to a number of of his mates.
9:05 p.m. — Alex Murdaugh says that he drives to go to his mom, Elizabeth “Libby” Murdaugh, in close by Varnville. He calls his son Buster, brother John Marvin, sister-in-law, Liz Murdaugh, and Chris Wilson on the drive.
9:20 p.m. — Murdaugh arrives at his mom’s home. He spends roughly 20 minutes visiting together with her and her nurses help Muschelle “Shelly” Smith.
9:45 p.m. — Murdaugh drives again to Moselle. One the best way he calls Chris Wilson on the cellphone.
10:00 p.m. — Murdaugh arrives again at Moselle.
10:05 p.m. — Murdaugh calls 911 saying that he has discovered his spouse and son shot to dying close to the canine kennels.
THE CASE AGAINST MURDAUGH
Alex Murdaugh is escorted from the Colleton County Courthouse after a judicial listening to earlier than Decide Clifton Newman on Monday, Aug. 29, 2022. Tracy Glantz [email protected]
Sept. 2, 2021 — A PMPED staffer finds a lacking examine on Murdaugh’s desk. It’s from Chris Wilson and was meant for the regulation agency.
Sept. 3, 2021 —Members of the PMPED regulation agency confront Murdaugh about lacking cash. He agrees to resign from the agency his household based.
Sept. 4, 2021 —Alex Murdaugh calls 911 saying that somebody shot him on the facet of a street whereas he modified a tire. The bullet is claimed to have grazed the again of his cranium. The story rapidly unravels and Murdaugh admits that he tried to kill himself with the assistance of Curtis Smith, a disabled former logger and distant relative of Murdaugh’s, so as to safe an insurance coverage payout for his surviving son, Buster. Smith is arrested however later denies in a NBC interview that he conspire with Murdaugh within the taking pictures. Smith says the gun went off when he tried to wrestle it out of a distraught Murdaugh’s hand.
Sept. 16, 2021 — Murdaugh turns himself in to police on expenses of insurance coverage fraud, conspiracy to commit insurance coverage fraud and falsifying a police report stemming from what authorities say is a botched staged homicide try.
Oct. 19, 2021 — Murdaugh returns to S.C. from a rehab facility in Florida and is indicted on a cost that he stole from the property of Gloria Satterfield, the household’s nanny who died following a fall at Moselle. He’s jailed on the Alvin S. Glenn Detention Middle in Richland County. Within the coming months he’s indicted on dozens of economic crime expenses, together with stealing from his personal shoppers and tax evasion.
July 14, 2022 — Murdaugh is formally charged with the homicide of his spouse and son.
The prosecution’s case
Because the curtain rises on the trial, there are few ensures about what proof the prosecution will carry towards Murdaugh.
However in court docket appearances and motions, lead prosecutor Creighton Waters has indicated he’ll argue that Murdaugh was pushed to kill his spouse and son in a craven try to distract from his monetary crimes.
“When this case began, lots of people assumed this was a homicide case, after which a few months later, some white-collar fraud thrown in there,” Waters mentioned in court docket. “However what we now have realized is that it is a white-collar case that culminated in two murders. That is an unbroken chain of mendacity, misappropriations and thefts.”
The prosecution has described Murdaugh as lurching from one prison scheme to a different after a sequence of dangerous land offers in 2008. Prosecutors will likely be trying to get as but unproven allegations in entrance of the jury: that Murdaugh stole cash from his personal regulation agency, pilfered settlements and looted conservatorship accounts belonging to his shoppers in an try to cowl his mounting money owed.
On June 7, 2021, the day of the murders, Murdaugh lastly ran out of street, prosecutors say. He had been subpoenaed to reveal monetary data as a part of a civil lawsuit over the 2019 boat crash that killed Mallory Seashore. On the morning of June 7, 2021, a employees member at PMPED, the regulation agency that Murdaugh’s household based, had inquired about lacking funds, prosecutors say.
It was “a day of reckoning,” Waters mentioned in court docket. For Murdaugh, who Waters described as having “by no means confronted accountability in his life,” homicide grew to become his solely approach out.
On the evening of June 7, 2021, Murdaugh used two completely different weapons to kill his spouse and son, prosecutors allege. Maggie was killed with bullets from a excessive powered rifle, whereas Paul was shot within the head and shoulder by a shotgun.
A diagram of the crime scene included in a report ready by Dr. Kenneth Lee Kinsey exhibiting the placement of Paul and Maggie Murdaugh’s our bodies relative to the kennels and storage shed. Colleton County Court docket
The prosecution has indicated that it has a video from Paul’s cellphone of Murdaugh, Paul and Maggie speaking on the canine kennels shortly earlier than the killing. The household’s weapons have been examined by SLED. However maybe most damning is the prosecution’s declare that the T-shirt worn by Alex Murdaugh the evening of the murders is roofed in again spatter, a sample of droplets attributable to the mist of blood when a projectile hits flesh.
Tom Bevel, a technical witness who analyzed the T-shirt, wrote in a report back to SLED:
“I don’t see some other mechanism to get so many misting stains onto (Murdaugh’s) shirt aside from the spatter created from the shotgun wounding (of Paul Murdaugh).”
The protection’s case
By means of the avalanche of indictments towards him, Murdaugh has maintained his innocence.
Murdaugh could have an opportunity to show it “by God and my nation,” as he requested at his arraignment, invoking an historical request for a jury trial.
Within the months main as much as the trial, his formidable protection staff has labored to chop the legs out from underneath the prosecution. They’ve attacked the state’s idea that Murdaugh killed his household to cover monetary crimes as “illogical” and “implausible”.
“There’s zero evidentiary help for this motive,” the protection wrote in a latest movement that argued the state shouldn’t be allowed to introduce the unproven monetary allegations contained in 17 different indictments towards Murdaugh.
In motions, the protection has portrayed the inquiry about lacking charges on the PMPED regulation agency as inconsequential. The attorneys additionally say the subpoena within the Mallory Seashore lawsuit would solely require Murdaugh to reveal superficial monetary data.
In actuality, Griffin and Harpootlian argue, there was no “day of reckoning.”
Murdaugh has additionally provided an alibi for the evening of June 7, 2021. He says that though he was on the household’s 1,700 acre searching property, Moselle, from 8:30 till simply after 9, he then drove to go to his mom in close by Varnville. Her nurse, Muschelle “Shelly” Smith, was additionally current, in line with the court docket submitting.
On the roughly 15-minute drive to and from his mom’s dwelling, he had cellphone conversations together with his son, Buster Murdaugh, brother John Marvin Murdaugh, sister-in-law Liz Murdaugh, pal Chris Wilson and C.B. Rowe, who’s believed to have helped across the property.
Murdaugh says he found the our bodies when he arrived again at Moselle at 10:05 p.m., when he made a frantic 911 name.
In one of the vital punishing pre-trial battles, the protection has fought to maintain the bloodstained T-shirt out of the courtroom. In a submitting Wednesday, the attorneys accused Bevel of participating in a “science truthful” experiment, twisted to provide a outcome favorable to the prosecution. Bevel’s first draft report said that the blood on the T-shirt was not in step with again spatter.
However after SLED brokers hand delivered the shirt to him so he might examine it once more, Bevel modified his thoughts and wrote a report saying that he had decided that the blood stains might solely have come from again spatter.
In a latest movement for sanctions, the protection argued that as a result of the prosecution has not turned over paperwork that might present how Bevel reached a brand new willpower, all testimony stemming from his evaluation of the shirt, which has since been destroyed, needs to be banned from court docket.
Investigators from SLED examined the cotton T-shirt that Alex Murdaugh wore the evening of the murders for blood utilizing two completely different chemical compounds that change shade within the presence of blood: Phenolphthalein, which turns pink, and leucocrystal violet, which turns blue when it reacts with hemoglobin, a protein contained in crimson blood cells. A protection movement alleges that on Feb. 15, 2022, investigators found that the shirt was “destroyed” after chemical compounds utilized to check for blood stained the whole shirt blue and sections have been lower from it to check for DNA and blood stains.
The protection doesn’t have to show that another person dedicated the crime. Nonetheless, the attorneys have beforehand accused Curtis Smith of committing the murders.
Harpootlian and Griffin wrote in a movement that Smith “decidedly” failed a polygraph examination administered by investigators.
“The rationale Smith failed the polygraph when requested if he murdered Maggie and Paul is as a result of he the truth is did commit these heinous crimes,” the protection attorneys wrote in October.
The prosecution might look to go off this argument. In latest motions they’ve requested Decide Newman to ban any inclusion of polygraph proof or any point out of so-called third social gathering guilt — proof that another person might have dedicated the crime.
Smith has additionally been indicted in reference to Murdaugh’s alleged embezzlement and cash laundering. He allegedly acquired greater than $1 million from Murdaugh over time. The prosecution subpoenaed Smith to testify at trial, in line with his lawyer, Aimee Zmroczek.
“The State instantly determined Alex was responsible,” the protection wrote in a latest movement. “The State has provided nothing greater than a fabricated motive, with none supporting proof.”
Tips on how to observe the trial
The State will likely be offering every day protection from contained in the Colleton County courthouse in Walterboro, SC. You may learn our protection on-line at www.thestate.com
Court docket TV will likely be broadcasting the trial reside. For extra details about streaming on-line, go to www.courttv.com/trending/alex-murdaugh-family-murders/
For tv viewers, go to www.courttv.com/where-to-watch/ to be taught which stations carry Court docket TV.
Observe extra of our reporting on Murdaugh household information and updates
See all tales
Ted Clifford is the crime and courts reporter at The State. He covers prison justice and public security within the Midlands and throughout South Carolina.