Why Muslim Feminists Are Turning In opposition to President Erdoğan

Şeyma Çetin is bursting with coloration: brilliant blue and pink eye shadow, a inexperienced half-sleeved shirt with denims, a tie, and an orange headband. Her garments and make-up stand out amongst different Turkish ladies in headscarves, and that’s Çetin’s purpose: to point out that it’s okay to be totally different. It’s a press release of defiance.

The headband was for a very long time a controversial image in Turkey, the place it was seen as a risk to the trendy republic’s secular origins. For Çetin, although, it symbolizes freedom of selection.

“That is a part of my political identification,” she says softly with a smile. “Society says loads about what a girl in a headband ought to do, however truly, we will do something.”

The 23-year-old pupil is amongst a rising variety of ladies who name themselves Muslim feminists—and who aren’t going to be boxed in by stereotypes. They belong to a brand new era of non secular ladies marked by their more and more vocal opposition to Turkey’s conservative authorities led by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

Learn Extra: How Ladies Activists in Turkey Preserve Preventing in a Local weather of Concern

Their moms noticed Erdoğan as an ally due to his lifting of a extremely contentious ban on sporting the headband in authorities workplaces in 2013. Earlier that yr, because the Gezi Park anti-government protests swept throughout Turkey, he had co-opted them as a constituency, describing them as “our sisters in headscarves.” However within the decade that adopted, many youthful non secular ladies like Çetin have shifted away from the President and his ruling Justice and Improvement Social gathering (AKP). They accuse the federal government of attempting to roll again the hard-won rights of Turkish ladies, together with eradicating authorized protections towards gender-based violence and severely limiting entry to abortion.

Rümeysa Çamdereli, Havle ladies’s organisation co-founder, in April 2023.

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

Havle members Seyma Çetin and Zeynep discover solidarity in one another by the day by day struggles they face, in Istanbul in April.

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

On Sunday, Erdogan will face the most important check of his 20 years in energy in elections seen as too near name. His recognition has been battered by rising dwelling prices exacerbated by a refusal to lift rates of interest to deliver hovering inflation underneath management; a sluggish response to a devastating earthquake that left at the very least 50,000 useless partially attributable to unregulated shoddy development, and rising authoritarianism that has led to a crackdown on the free press and a ban on practically all anti-government protests. That features the annual Ladies’s Day March in Istanbul, which for years has included an rising variety of ladies in headscarves—an indication that the Muslim feminist motion is rising and changing into extra vocal.

Learn Extra: Unique: The Man Who Might Beat Erdoğan

Some, like Çetin, belong to a Muslim feminist group named Havle, which has round 200 members. This March, as in earlier years, hundreds of girls gathered, at the same time as riot police tried to disband them with tear fuel.

“I grew up with Erdoğan’s authorities, and at first, we have been capable of collect and protest with out teargas,” Çetin says. “Now our proper to freedom of expression and protest is being met with violence. This authorities fears every thing from everybody. We’d like a authorities that permits us to criticize it.”

READ MORE  South African prosecutors seek extradition orders in the case of $580K stolen from the president

Erdoğan nonetheless has a big base of help amongst conservative ladies, however a ballot by The Social Democracy Basis, a Turkish NGO, discovered a 3rd of the ladies who voted for him within the 2018 elections mentioned they might not achieve this on this election.

Seyma Çetin, 23, a Havle member and ladies’s rights activist, photographed in Istanbul in Might. She says her headband is a part of her political identification.

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission


Throughout Erdoğan’s first decade in energy, ladies’s rights activists had main wins, partly due to strain from civil society and partly to fulfill necessities for European Union membership—a one-time ambition for Turkey. New legal guidelines launched marriage equality, criminalized marital rape, and raised the authorized age of marriage to 18. Employers have been barred from firing pregnant ladies and the federal government supplied extra monetary help for working moms, enabling them to affix the workforce. In 2011, Turkey turned the primary nation to ratify the Istanbul Conference, which units out legal guidelines and insurance policies to fight gender-based violence.

However in recent times, lots of these positive factors have been misplaced or come underneath risk as the federal government has cooled on E.U. membership and allied with right-wing Islamist events. In 2021, Turkey withdrew from the Istanbul Conference, saying it “normalized” homosexuality and ran counter to household values—a transfer Human Rights Watch decried as a “main reversal for efforts to fight gender-based violence and promote ladies’s rights.” The AKP has proposed lowering the abortion restrict from 10 weeks to 6 (when ladies typically don’t but know they’re pregnant), and altering the statutory rape regulation in order that older males wouldn’t go to jail for marrying underage ladies. They retreated on these proposals solely after protests by ladies’s rights campaigners. And in follow, abortion entry has turn into harder. In keeping with a 2020 report from Kadir Has College in Istanbul, solely 185 out of 295 public hospitals licensed to present abortions supplied the process. The remainder reportedly turned ladies away, telling them docs didn’t need to do it.

Learn Extra: Angelina Jolie Talks to Elif Shafak About Why Males Must Be Engaged within the Struggle for Ladies’s Rights

In the meantime, Erdoğan’s presidential rival Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu has promised to rejoin the Istanbul Conference and supply extra help for victims of gender-based violence, which Havle members see as one of many main threats to ladies. They’re looking for to lift consciousness about ladies’s authorized rights in Turkey by social media and occasions and protect remaining authorized protections. The variety of femicides and suspicious deaths of girls in Turkey has steadily risen during the last decade to hit 579 in 2022, in response to knowledge compiled by the marketing campaign group We Will Cease Femicide Platform. (Authorities knowledge for the interval isn’t obtainable.)

READ MORE  Giuliani says Trump is “actually, actually upset” about Peter Navarro's contempt conviction

Zeynep, a 28-year-old LGBTQ+ member of the Havle group, holds a banner that claims “La Havle” in April. “La Havle” is an Arabic phrase that may be translated as “For crying out loud.”

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

Zeynep, who requested to be recognized solely by her first title, says “I need to be an instance that we may be Muslim, queer and put on a headband.”

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

Muslim feminists are utilizing their understanding of Islamic scriptures to combat again, looking for to sway rural conservative communities that type the AKP’s pure political heartland. They clarify that the Quran provides ladies rights to divorce and to obtain alimony, inheritance and safety from violence. ”We share our experiences or use our views and feedback on points. We’re not a spiritual establishment however non secular ladies who need freedom to have the ability to speak about our manner of understanding faith,” says Havle co-founder Rümeysa Çamdereli.

Çamdereli tells different ladies she is a divorced single mom who struggled to have a romantic life after her marriage ended. She says her household disapproved of her having a boyfriend and thought she ought to dedicate her life to motherhood. However she now not feels that being an excellent Muslim ought to imply giving up on love.


For a lot of, the battle begins at dwelling.

“Feminism for me is a battle in your individual home. It’s a day by day a part of your life,” says Sıla Öztürk, 32, a Havle member who has a younger son and is learning for a doctorate. Öztürk’s mom Mualla Gülnaz Kavuncu wrote articles in protection of Islamic feminism within the Eighties, however she says her mom nonetheless talks about parenting as largely a girl’s accountability. Öztürk has needed to persuade her husband to alter diapers, despite the fact that he’s usually a supportive accomplice. “I’m combating all of them. I cry a lot and really feel so insufficient generally,” she says.

Berfu Şeker, advocacy coordinator for Ladies for Ladies’s Human Rights in Turkey, says the brand new era of non secular ladies are armed with extra information of their rights by the web and better training. They see ladies’s roles in Islam very otherwise from their authorities.

“The ruling authorities, because it got here to energy in 2002, began implementing insurance policies that outline ladies as obedient models of the household,” says Seker, including that the federal government makes use of non secular ideas to legitimize gender inequality. Below its view of Islam, organic intercourse dictates a division of labor and lifestyle—Erdoğan says ladies ought to get married and have three youngsters. Muslim feminists imagine Islam isn’t so inflexible.

Sıla Öztürk, 32, is a Havle member who has a younger son and is learning for a doctorate. “Feminism for me is a battle in your individual home. It’s a day by day a part of your life,” she says.

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

A element of Şeyma Çetin’s outfit. The 23-year-old pupil is amongst a rising variety of ladies who name themselves Muslim feminists—and who aren’t going to be boxed in by stereotypes.

READ MORE  French President Macron joins India's Republic Day celebrations as chief guest

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

Havle conducts analysis and surveys, in topics like early marriage, and shares their findings with preachers and non secular training academics. The group holds workshops concerning the rights of motherhood, divorce, jobs exterior the house, and home violence. They work with municipalities to succeed in marginalized ladies.

“We don’t speak about feminism with them. We simply present them defend themselves,” says Zeynep, a 28-year-old LGBTQ+ member of the group who requested to be recognized solely by her first title, fearing persecution. Zeynep says lots of the ladies they work with are unaware of their rights underneath Islam. She and different Havle members educate them about their rights to be protected towards violence and to have property of their very own. Additionally they assist them perceive the place they’ll entry assist in the event that they undergo home violence. However they don’t explicitly focus on feminism, which is seen by many in Turkey as a Western ideology that goes towards household values.

Different Havle members have negotiated for extra ladies’s worship areas in mosques, the place males dominate. A weblog known as ‘Reçel’ which implies ‘Fruit Jam’ based by Havle co-founder Çamdereli provides non secular ladies the area to put in writing anonymously about their private lives.

Regardless of being comparatively cautious, the group has sparked some ire. After placing its title to a press release objecting to a authorized modification that may take away rights for LGBTQ+ folks, posters have been held on Havle’s workplace doorways.

“We have been accused of spying and subjected to insults on-line. We obtained dying threats. A poster was held on the door of our deal with registered with Google,” says Çamdereli, who had beforehand had an nameless on-line dying risk made towards her.

Different feminist organizations in Turkey additionally face threats. The We Will Cease Femicide Platform, a non-profit group that helps victims of home violence and their households, is being prosecuted and might be shut down if discovered responsible. Melek Arı, a member of the platform, says the indictment accuses them of insulting the president on Twitter and holds a board member in contempt of the regulation for attending banned protests, corresponding to ladies’s marches.

Zeynep says the rules of justice and equality are central to Islam. Her objectives for Havle are to additional inclusivity in a rustic that has seen Pleasure marches banned and prejudice harnessed as a political device to co-opt conservative communities.

“What we’re doing—ladies’s rights and feminism—is a follow of Muslimhood,” she says. “I need to be an instance that we may be Muslim, queer, and put on a headband.”

A protester shouts at a feminist night time march in Istanbul on March 8, 2022.

Özge Sebzeci for the Fuller Mission

—With reporting by Leslie Dickstein and Julia Zorthian/New York

This story was reported with the help of the Nationwide Geographic Society and printed in partnership with The Fuller Mission, a nonprofit newsroom devoted to the protection of girls’s points world wide. Join The Fuller Mission’s publication, and comply with them on Twitter or LinkedIn.

Extra Should-Reads From TIME


Contact us at [email protected].

Leave a Comment