Warning: This text accommodates SPOILERS for You season 4, half 2.You has been teasing season 4’s Rhys twist since manner again in You season 1. Penn Badgley’s Joe Goldberg has lengthy struggled with two sides of himself – the darkish killer and the great particular person he believes he actually is. Nevertheless, every You season sees Joe’s crumbling psyche proceed to provide manner. Simply when Joe seems to be making progress, he takes steps backward. You season 4 illustrates this with the Eat The Wealthy killer twist.
SCREENRANT VIDEO OF THE DAY
You season 4, half 1 ended with the reveal that Rhys Montrose was the Eat The Wealthy killer. But, You season 4, half 2 doesn’t take lengthy to indicate Joe killing the actual Rhys Montrose, thus revealing that Joe has been hallucinating Rhys as his killer self. This isn’t the primary time that Joe has hallucinated, however that is the primary time that Joe has killed offscreen and attributed the deaths to another person. This revelation exhibits how far gone Joe’s psyche is, and the way distant he’s from turning into a greater particular person.
Associated: 6 Largest You Theories After Season 4
You Season 4’s Joe Killer Twist By means of Rhys Was Set Up From The Begin
Joe’s hallucinations had been encouraging him to maintain his killer behavior going since You season 1. Usually, Joe’s earlier hallucinations had been triggered by medicine, equivalent to in You season 2 the place Forty drugged him with LSD to assist the inventive technique of his screenplay. This led to among the most fascinating Joe character work in You, the place he was pressured to confront his demons whereas locked in a room and compelled to put in writing about Beck. Whereas tripping on LSD, Joe hallucinated his mom within the lavatory, who informed him that individuals like them by no means change. She tried to get him to kill Forty, which parallels the Rhys hallucination twist in You season 4.
Throughout his LSD journey, Joe additionally hallucinated blood on his arms. Whereas he was on a mind-altering substance, these hallucinations confirmed Joe was at warfare with himself. Joe’s internal battle has been raging for 4 seasons, however You season 4 lastly noticed Joe give his different half a reputation and a face. Hallucinating Rhys because the Eat the Wealthy killer may need gone additional than any earlier Joe hallucination, nevertheless it was clearly foreshadowed by way of his earlier visions.
Why You Season 4’s Rhys Twist Labored So Properly
Since You has been build up the Eat the Wealthy killer twist for 4 seasons, the pay-off was strengthened significantly. You season 4, half 1 ended by framing Rhys as an actual particular person and separate from Joe. You season 4, half 2 flips this reveal on its head and proves but once more that Joe is just not able to true change. It could have appeared that Joe was doing higher in London, however he was not consciously conscious of what he was nonetheless indulging in. Had Joe by no means hallucinated earlier than, this may appear to be a weak revelation, however his earlier experiences laid the proper groundwork for the Rhys twist.
Whereas You had been teasing Joe’s psyche splitting for 4 seasons, the Rhys reveal labored to problem the viewers’s belief in Joe as a narrator. In previous seasons, You has demonstrated Joe as an unreliable narrator, however You season 4 takes this to a brand new degree which may probably alter the present ceaselessly. You season 5 has not been confirmed, but when the story does proceed, it is going to be fascinating to see how far Joe will go into the darkest depths of his thoughts.
Extra: You Season 4 Half 2’s 10 Largest Unanswered Questions