The Big Picture
Clint Eastwood’s decision to significantly cut his character’s dialogue in the
Dollars Trilogy
made him iconic, keeping the mysterious Man With No Name elusive and intriguing.
The lack of dialogue in
A Fistful of Dollars
enhanced the character’s strength and mystery.
Eastwood’s portrayal as the Man With No Name set a standard for silent Hollywood heroes.
Is there a more famous Clint Eastwood character out there than the infamous Man With No Name from Sergio Leone’s Dollars Trilogy? Okay, “Dirty” Harry Callahan certainly comes close, but Eastwood’s Western icon is often considered the absolute standard for the wandering gunslinger archetype, firmly establishing all the usual tropes that we associate with such protagonists. The Old West was a dangerous place, and with characters like the Man With No Name, Eastwood makes it an even more mysterious one also. But there was one move in particular that the actor made while filming A Fistful of Dollars that turned the Man With No Name into the very staple we know him as today. It’s a simple yet profound change that shifted our entire perspective on the character: he cut down on his dialogue.
A Fistful of Dollars
A Fistful of Dollars is a spaghetti Western film from director Sergio Leone starring Clint Eastwood. A Fistful of Dollars is notable for being Clint Eastwood’s big break in Hollywood and also for being the beginning of the “Dollars Trilogy.” The film was followed by For a Few Dollars More in 1965 and The Good, The Bad and the Ugly in 1966.
Release Date January 18, 1964
Director Sergio Leone , Monte Hellman
Cast Clint Eastwood , Marianne Koch , Gian Maria Volonte , Wolfgang Lukschy , Sieghardt Rupp , Joseph Egger
Runtime 99
Writers Ryûzô Kikushima , Akira Kurosawa , A. Bonzzoni , Víctor Andrés Catena , Sergio Leone , Jaime Comas Gil
Tagline In his own way he is perhaps, the most dangerous man who ever lived!
Expand
“Less Is More” Was Clint Eastwood’s Western Mantra
Part of the reason we care so much about the Man With No Name is because of how little we know about him. From what we can tell, he’s an honorable man, and he often fights on behalf of the little guy (or, at least, fights against a bigger guy). When we first meet him, we aren’t even sure if he is the hero or the villain, but as he continues to slowly reveal more about himself, his side in the conflict becomes clear. With all that Eastwood charm, we can’t help but be drawn to the Man With No Name, and that’s by design. Though the screenplay for A Fistful of Dollars initially revealed more about this mysterious drifter through choice dialogue, Clint Eastwood felt that would’ve been too distracting from the image he was hoping to convey with this picture.
“The part wasn’t as spare as was in the script,” Eastwood told the BBC while on set in 1977. “But to me, the more the character would get into expository scenes and start explaining things, the more it would dissipate the mystery of the character or the strength of the character.” Because of this, Eastwood and director Sergio Leone cut down the script immensely, hoping to make the Man With No Name character into something a bit more unique. “You’re not quite sure who he is,” Eastwood elaborated. “You’re not even quite sure he’s the hero until three-quarters or halfway through the film.” Leone had no problem with trimming down the screenplay to its barest bones — in fact, the director himself notes that many of his pictures are “basically silent films,” noting that the dialogue just adds extra depth.
Related The Surprising History Behind One of Clint Eastwood’s Most Iconic Quotes
And Eastwood may not have even been the first to say it!
This is very much the case in The Dollars Trilogy, which thrives on its ability to tell a powerful tale without the use of many words. Naturally, the Man With No Name is a man of few words also, and given that his own “name” shifts and changes with the wind (he goes by Joe, Manco, or Blondie, depending on the picture), it keeps us from really getting to know much about him. Actor and comedian Jim Carrey once said that Eastwood played the Man With No Name so that we, the audience, could insert our own there instead. There’s something remarkably true to that statement. Because this character didn’t have a true name of his own, we could become him. By the time it was clear he was the hero (or “The Good,” if you will), it was equally clear that he was the type we might hope to be.
The Mystery Behind Clint Eastwood’s Man With No Name Gives Him Power
How much can you really say about a man who says hardly anything at all? Garbed with a poncho, a cigarillo, and those trademark cowboy boots, the Man With No Name wanders aimlessly about the desert lands of the mythic Old West generating a myth of his own with each step. Clint Eastwood’s coolness as the character stands in stark contrast to his famous television role of Rowdy Yates (especially in Rawhide’s earlier years) and stretches his worth as an actor. He’s always calm, collected, and wears a poker face even better than he does that brown hat on his unkempt head. To say that the look and feel of the Man With No Name isn’t essential to the character himself is to misunderstand the whole concept.
It’s the mystery behind this character that makes him both elusive and interesting. We don’t know where he comes from or where he’s going. All we know is what he’s doing right now, at any given moment. This is an even greater advantage to his character than the six-shooter strapped to his hip, as it keeps his enemies at bay and his allies far enough from immediate danger. “What you know about the Man comes from his actions,” explained comic book writer Christos Gage, who penned Dynamite Entertainment’s The Man With No Name, a comic book sequel to The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly. “He is what he does.” That’s exactly the idea that Eastwood was hoping to convey with his portrayal of the Western hero, who became notable largely because of his “act first, talk never” approach.
Part of what makes The Man With No Name such an important icon for the Western genre is the air of strangeness that surrounds him. Unlike John Wayne’s Western heroes, who are generally more outgoing and boisterous, Eastwood’s trademark character would rather not retaliate at all. But when he sees an injustice done to another, especially those who cannot help themselves, the Man With No Name steps up to the challenge. This type of Hollywood hero that Leone and Eastwood created would go on to be copied, parodied, and emulated by countless others, from Boba Fett in Star Wars to the leading character in Stephen King’s The Dark Tower series. Most recently, Walton Goggins’ “The Ghoul” from the Fallout television series evokes a very “Man With No Name” demeanor. In fact, Goggins has since admitted that The Dollars Trilogy was his primary inspiration for the role.
Clint Eastwood Became an Instant Western Star After ‘The Dollars Trilogy’
Although Clint Eastwood had been one of the leading stars on Rawhide for years — and likely would’ve continued if not for the infamous rural purge — before making A Fistful of Dollars, the actor eventually used the Spaghetti Western to launch his career as a well-known and respected movie star. Throughout the ’60s and ’70s, Eastwood made a name for himself as a Hollywood actor, appearing in two dozen pictures during that time. Though he didn’t always appear in Westerns (the Dirty Harry movies were also fairly popular), his name remained synonymous with the genre — and still does even now. It’s no wonder that he and John Wayne were at odds given their respective claim to the “Western King” title. As Eastwood began establishing himself as a director, the filmmaker returned to the Western for Pale Rider (his only horse opera of the ’80s) and ultimately Unforgiven, which effectively concluded his tenure as the face of the then fading genre.
Of course, even as Eastwood continued to star in thrillers and direct notable true stories, he could never escape the Western entirely. 30 years after Unforgiven, Eastwood tackled the neo-Western period drama, Cry Macho, in which he plays the closest thing to a traditional cowboy that he had in decades. Although not your usual shoot-’em-up action feature, it was a return to form that felt natural for the longtime Western actor, despite the years in between. Though Clint Eastwood has yet to return to the traditional Western, there’s little doubt that no role will be as memorable as the infamous Man With No Name, a character who remains one of the mightiest pillars of the genre even to this day.
The Dollars Trilogy is available to stream on Max in the U.S.
Watch on Max