Touch upon this storyComment
KYIV, Ukraine — For the reason that starting of Russia’s full-scale invasion, Poland has been amongst Ukraine’s staunchest supporters, offering army and financial support, taking in hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian refugees, championing Kyiv’s place in worldwide boards, and remodeling its territory into the principle conduit for Western arms shipments sure for the entrance strains.
However even among the many closest of mates, critical quarrels can come up.
Final week, Polish and Ukrainian officers clashed overtly, after Marcin Przydacz, a overseas coverage adviser to Polish President Andrzej Duda, stated that Ukraine ought to “begin appreciating the function that Poland has performed for Ukraine in latest months and years.” His remarks have been in response to a rising dispute between Kyiv and Warsaw over Ukrainian grain exports into Poland, during which Ukrainian Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal had known as Poland’s actions “unfriendly and populist.”
Below a deal brokered by the European Union, Poland and 4 different neighboring nations are allowed to ban Ukrainian grain imports to guard their home farmers, however enable the grain to cross their territory into different nations. The settlement is about to run out on Sept. 15, however Przydacz and different Polish officers have known as for extending the restrictions.
“Ukraine actually acquired quite a lot of assist from Poland,” Przydacz stated in an interview with Polish radio in late July. “What’s most necessary immediately is defending the curiosity of the Polish farmer.”
Grain gross sales are an acute, if not existential, problem for Kyiv after Russia stepped up bombing of Ukraine’s Black Sea ports final month, reducing the principle export routes to international markets.
Ukraine’s Overseas Ministry summoned Polish Ambassador Bartosz Cichocki for discussions on Aug. 1, after Przydacz’s feedback. The next day, Polish officers known as in Ukrainian Ambassador Vasyl Zvarych for the same speak.
Relations with Ukraine in the meanwhile are “not the most effective,” Polish Deputy Overseas Minister Pawel Jablonski informed Polish radio. Ukraine “shouldn’t assault its allies,” he added.
Przydacz’s feedback, and the following back-and-forth between the capitals, don’t appear to pose a risk to Ukraine’s shut relations with Poland, which date again to the beginning of Ukraine’s independence.
However the dispute additionally underlined the balancing act that Ukraine faces in making an attempt to sq. its personal urgent wants with these of its neighbors and supporters — allies on whom Kyiv now relies upon for its very existence — whereas additionally making an attempt to reduce any variations of opinion that Moscow might exploit.
The strain additionally factors to exhaustion and frayed nerves because the Russian invasion nears the 18th-month mark, leaving some observers anxious.
“I’m frightened about this as a result of, you recognize, the historical past just isn’t given, it’s not predetermined,” stated Tymofiy Mylovanov, head of the Kyiv Faculty of Economics. “Actions of people, particularly political leaders, matter — matter lots,” he stated. “And I believe errors could possibly be made, and if errors are made, there could be a rift between Poland and Ukraine.”
F-16 coaching for Ukrainian pilots faces delays and uncertainty
To this point, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and prime Polish officers have managed to stifle any flash factors between their nations, together with an incident final 12 months when a stray Ukrainian antiaircraft missile apparently landed in Poland, killing two Polish residents.
In response to the grain dispute, Zelensky, writing on the social media previously often called Twitter, stated that “political moments” shouldn’t spoil relations between the 2 nations and “feelings ought to positively settle down.”
He additionally pressured that Ukraine tremendously appreciated “the historic assist of Poland, which along with us has turn out to be an actual protect of Europe.”
“And there can’t be a single crack on this protect,” he added.
However there may be the potential for just a few cracks, on condition that Poland as soon as managed giant parts of Ukraine, and the 2 nations share an advanced and typically bitter historical past.
In July, Zelensky and Duda marked the eightieth anniversary of occasions throughout World Battle II, during which members of Ukrainian rebel items, preventing to determine an unbiased Ukrainian state, launched brutal assaults on Polish villages within the Volyn area, now in western Ukraine, killing tens of hundreds.
Zelensky joined Duda for a spiritual ceremony within the western Ukrainian metropolis of Lutsk to commemorate the occasions — a gesture of reconciliation that was extremely appreciated by Polish officers.
Nonetheless, in style narratives in Poland and Ukraine nonetheless differ tremendously about what transpired 80 years in the past.
Poles name what occurred the “Volyn bloodbath” and say it was half of a bigger effort by Ukrainian forces to ethnically cleanse Poles from the area. Ukrainian nationalists say the occasions have been the results of an ongoing wrestle between Poles and Ukrainians on the time.
Duda and Zelensky collectively tweeted they have been honoring “all harmless victims” of Volyn. However in a possible reflection of the divide between their nations, Duda wrote in a separate tweet that he had joined Zelensky to “pay tribute to murdered Poles.”
The Volyn occasions are important to a small however vocal minority of nationalist and far-right teams in Poland. Ukrainian information shops reported in July that followers at a soccer match within the Polish metropolis of Wroclaw unfurled banners saying “Ukrainians murdered youngsters in Volyn” and “80 years of shameful silence for Volyn.”
“There are two delicate points between Poland and Ukraine. The primary is historical past, and it’s been an outdated downside for years,” stated Wojciech Kononczuk, director of the Polish-government funded Centre for Jap Research. “The opposite problematic level is the query of this Ukrainian grain.”
Sluggish counteroffensive darkens temper in Ukraine
With farmers a significant voting base for Poland’s governing Legislation and Justice social gathering, the grain problem has been significantly contentious for the Polish authorities, which faces elections this fall.
The far-right Confederation social gathering has additionally mounted a marketing campaign towards what it describes because the “Ukrainization of Poland.” Ballot numbers recommend that the far-right social gathering might find yourself performing as kingmaker after the mid-October elections, elevating considerations that its members might search to scale back Poland’s assist for Kyiv.
Kononczuk stated there have been “some emotional steps and selections” by Ukrainian and Polish officers.
He stated the summoning of the Polish ambassador in Kyiv to the Ukrainian Overseas Ministry was met with shock in Warsaw, particularly as Cichocki is amongst a handful of ambassadors who remained in Kyiv through the Russian siege and has been one in every of Ukraine’s strongest diplomatic backers.
However “sympathies between Poles and Ukrainians are at an unprecedented stage,” Kononczuk stated, helped by “frequent notion of the safety threats” posed by Russia.
Nonetheless, the grain dispute just isn’t going away.
Ukraine’s agriculture minister, Mykola Solskyi, insists that restrictions on Ukrainian imports into neighboring nations have to be lifted as quickly as potential.
“What would be the penalties if [Ukrainian farmers] don’t survive this 12 months?” Solskyi requested in an interview. This was “a unprecedented scenario, even throughout an election interval,” he stated.
Yandex co-founder calls battle ‘barbaric,’ signaling dismay in Russian elite
The European Union loosened rules on Ukrainian farm exports at the start of Russia’s invasion, to assist the Ukrainian financial system, during which agriculture is a significant sector. Grain exports to Ukraine’s neighbors surged.
Nonetheless, in response to the soar in imports, in addition to a drop in grain costs worldwide, the European Union in Could permitted Poland, Bulgaria, Hungary, Romania and Slovakia to dam home gross sales of Ukrainian wheat, maize, rapeseed and sunflower seeds, whereas permitting them to transit to different nations. Nonetheless, for Ukraine producers, exporting by land farther than to neighboring nations inside the European Union sharply will increase transportation prices.
Solskyi stated he believed that Russia’s latest choice to desert a United Nations-brokered deal that allowed grain shipments from Black Sea ports was triggered by the choice to limit Ukrainian exports in neighboring nations, which gave the Kremlin a strain level to make use of to squeeze the Ukrainian financial system.
“All of us perceive that it’s most worthwhile for us to go by sea and probably the most handy for our neighbors,” he stated. “However our neighbors ought to perceive that step one for us to journey by sea is to carry their bans.”
Nonetheless, Solskyi stated he was not frightened concerning the tensions that the dispute has created with Poland as “there aren’t any actual mates and actual companions with out dialogue.”
“Take my greatest mates,” he stated. “If we don’t argue as soon as each two or three months, then one thing is lacking.”
Morris reported from Berlin. Serhiy Morgunov in Stuttgart, Germany, contributed to this report.
Understanding the Russia-Ukraine battle
View 3 extra tales